As an update, I hooked up an old MP3 player to the line in inputs and there were no volume issues. I swapped out my phono preamp for an ART Precision Phono Pre, which has adjustable gain. With the gain cranked to the max on the phone preamp, the Wiim pre-gain maxed out, and the amp volume maxed out the turntable output was audible (not loud, but louder than a whisper) but really badly distorted. Going to swap out a turntable from another room and see if that makes any difference.Good question - that I haven't done. Will check tonight.