Completed Beta: Room Correction for Android

[jmudrick]

Maybe the price at miniDSP doesn't include taxes and shipping. Over £100 always puts me off

No it doesn't.

 

[slartibartfast]

The 1 is around 110 € solo in Germany. Bought mine in a bundle with the 2x4HD to DDRC-24.

​

Cheapest I've seen in the UK is around £115 including shipping. Amazon is £121

 

[deanerino]

Yep. a little bit of a chore getting my samsung tablet to cooperate, but yeah. The Neumi's (speakers) have a cabinet resonance /bass glitch. The curve room correcton applied looks a little like a negative image of what I saw from some reviewers and the music souonds a little fuller. Honestly it sounds almost like I remember it. So, bravo to the idea of giving us better music through technology! Job well done!

 

[Wiimer]

umik-1 costs 30,000 JPY (190 USD) in Japan.
I'll wait until IMM-6C becomes available.


In case you are wondering, here are the results measured on 4 Android devices.

(This is a superimposed graph of RC's "Measured". May contain some errors.)


Edit:
All RC target curves were set to "flat", but 12T was corrected as B&K. (I noticed this later.)



LG V60




Xiaomi 12T pro






Xiaomi 13T pro




Galaxy Tab S8 plus






Fixed to an arm stand.

 

[jmudrick]

In case you are wondering, here are the results measured on 4 Android devices.

13T obviously broke in the bass but disappointing to see so much variance at 50hz among the others.

 

[Wiimer]

Personally, I would not want to use the RC of the built-in microphone, but if could use it, it would be in the 100Hz-4kHz range. I am now done with my beta testing and will return to my PEQ.

 

[jmudrick]

Personally, I would not want to use the RC of the built-in microphone, but if could use it, it would be in the 100Hz-4kHz range. I am now done with my beta testing and will return to my PEQ.

It's a very crude measurement system compared with ARC, Dirac etc. I'll limit to below 300hz.

 

[SkintAudio]

I used my son's iPhone to test the RC and was pleasantly surprised by the difference it made.
Having now tried the beta on my android phone, I can say the results are very similar.
Absolutely delighted

 

[Smartplug]

I used my son's iPhone to test the RC and was pleasantly surprised by the difference it made.
Having now tried the beta on my android phone, I can say the results are very similar.
Absolutely delighted

When RC was in beta on iOS, it did not sound good. I left it off till one day RC became available for official release and my unit updated to the official. I rerun the rc and the first that came to my mouth wow. How did wiim do this? Wiim secret sauce!

 

[bherren]

So I tested RC using a Pixel 8 Pro, a USB jack adapter that came with my previous phone (pixel 7) which is unbranded and an iMM-6 calibrated mic (jack).

The RC was set to correct from 40Hz to 4k (default) with 10dB max.

The first two pictures are the results:


And here we is the result of doing the calibration on an iPad with the same iMM-6 microphone:

The end results are quite similar which is encouraging

It also sounds pretty good. I find that it dampens the lower bass a tad too much so for my personal use I limited the bass correction to 5dB, but this is probably a matter of personal taste.

My speakers are rear ported with a pretty low bass extension (Philharmonic Audio BMR Monitors) and are too close to the wall (for practical reasons).

A couple of minor bugs I noticed: after the correction is complete, when going back to the settings menu, EQ still shows 'off' (despite being enabled) and so does 'Room correction'. actually going into those panels and back out fixed it.

Additional suggestions:

* Display clearly which microphone is being used. In my case it seems it did use the external one due to the similarity of results when using the iPad with it, but I can't be sure and some testers on the forum expressed doubts.

* Provide a way to upload the external microphone calibration data

* Save the nice graph of measurements obtained at the end of correction so it can be re-displayed easily and/or saved as a picture. it's useful when exchanging with others or comparing multiple measurements

(I've also sent a ticket with the above)

Overall pretty happy with this !

 

[slartibartfast]

So I tested RC using a Pixel 8 Pro, a USB jack adapter that came with my previous phone (pixel 7) which is unbranded and an iMM-6 calibrated mic (jack).

The RC was set to correct from 40Hz to 4k (default) with 10dB max.

The first two pictures are the results:
View attachment 9341
View attachment 9342
And here we is the result of doing the calibration on an iPad with the same iMM-6 microphone:
View attachment 9343
The end results are quite similar which is encouraging

It also sounds pretty good. I find that it dampens the lower bass a tad too much so for my personal use I limited the bass correction to 5dB, but this is probably a matter of personal taste.

My speakers are rear ported with a pretty low bass extension (Philharmonic Audio BMR Monitors) and are too close to the wall (for practical reasons).

A couple of minor bugs I noticed: after the correction is complete, when going back to the settings menu, EQ still shows 'off' (despite being enabled) and so does 'Room correction'. actually going into those panels and back out fixed it.

Additional suggestions:

* Display clearly which microphone is being used. In my case it seems it did use the external one due to the similarity of results when using the iPad with it, but I can't be sure and some testers on the forum expressed doubts.

* Provide a way to upload the external microphone calibration data

* Save the nice graph of measurements obtained at the end of correction so it can be re-displayed easily and/or saved as a picture. it's useful when exchanging with others or comparing multiple measurements

(I've also sent a ticket with the above)

Overall pretty happy with this !

It does tell you which mic is being used.

 

[slartibartfast]

So I tested RC using a Pixel 8 Pro, a USB jack adapter that came with my previous phone (pixel 7) which is unbranded and an iMM-6 calibrated mic (jack).

The RC was set to correct from 40Hz to 4k (default) with 10dB max.

The first two pictures are the results:
View attachment 9341
View attachment 9342
And here we is the result of doing the calibration on an iPad with the same iMM-6 microphone:
View attachment 9343
The end results are quite similar which is encouraging

It also sounds pretty good. I find that it dampens the lower bass a tad too much so for my personal use I limited the bass correction to 5dB, but this is probably a matter of personal taste.

My speakers are rear ported with a pretty low bass extension (Philharmonic Audio BMR Monitors) and are too close to the wall (for practical reasons).

A couple of minor bugs I noticed: after the correction is complete, when going back to the settings menu, EQ still shows 'off' (despite being enabled) and so does 'Room correction'. actually going into those panels and back out fixed it.

Additional suggestions:

* Display clearly which microphone is being used. In my case it seems it did use the external one due to the similarity of results when using the iPad with it, but I can't be sure and some testers on the forum expressed doubts.

* Provide a way to upload the external microphone calibration data

* Save the nice graph of measurements obtained at the end of correction so it can be re-displayed easily and/or saved as a picture. it's useful when exchanging with others or comparing multiple measurements

(I've also sent a ticket with the above)

Overall pretty happy with this !

I just jumped out of bed to try your method using the iMM6, a TRRS to USB adaptor and the Pixel USB adaptor. Room Correction still claimed to be using the built-in mic. I have no idea what is going on.

 

[slartibartfast]

I have an Android app called "Recorder" which recognises "External microphone (3.5mm)" or "External microphone (USB)" so it must be possible for WiiM to do the same.

 

[bherren]

I just jumped out of bed to try your method using the iMM6, a TRRS to USB adaptor and the Pixel USB adaptor. Room Correction still claimed to be using the built-in mic. I have no idea what is going on.

Maybe that's what it did for me and the built-in mic is just 'good enough'. I'll try again later and check/compare. Another possibility is that the app doesn't yet know how to display what Mic is being used.

 

[crushed]

What does this eq say about me? Apple and Android was nearly the same.

 

[slartibartfast]

Maybe that's what it did for me and the built-in mic is just 'good enough'. I'll try again later and check/compare. Another possibility is that the app doesn't yet know how to display what Mic is being used.

I did get some weird results which looked like nothing was recorded which I suppose would happen if it tried to use the disabled built-in mic. I have no idea.

 

[bherren]

What does this eq say about me? Apple and Android was nearly the same.

Speakers a bit close to the walls causing the bass to 'boom' and thus RC to damp it down heavily maybe ?

 

[slartibartfast]

Here is another thought. I get different results if I point the top or the bottom of my Pixel 3a towards the speakers. As far as I know there are microphones at both ends. Which one should be used?

 

[harkpabst]

No joy with Xiaomi 12 so far.



Feedback sent.

 

[Brantome]

No joy with Xiaomi 12 so far.

View attachment 9349

Feedback sent.

I get that with my Dayton Imm-6c. Ticket submitted.